March 10, 2021 — One of many nation’s prime medical analysis journals is going through requires an investigation after a controversial — and since deleted — podcast questioned whether or not structural racism exists.
Greater than 2,000 folks have signed a petition on Change.org calling for an investigation at JAMA — the journal of the American Medical Affiliation — after the February podcast, known as “Structural Racism for Medical doctors: What Is It?”
The host of the podcast, Edward Livingston, MD, deputy editor at JAMA for scientific opinions and training, has additionally been criticized. In the course of the podcast, Livingston, who’s white, stated, “Structural racism is an unlucky time period. Personally, I believe taking racism out of the dialog will assist. Many people are offended by the idea that we’re racist.”
Now, Livingston’s standing at JAMA is unclear. Requested if Livingston nonetheless labored for the journal, a JAMA spokesperson would solely say, “No remark.”
The audio of podcast has been deleted from JAMA’s web site. Instead is audio of an announcement from JAMA Editor-in-Chief Howard Bauchner, MD. In his assertion, which he launched final week, he stated the feedback within the podcast, which additionally featured Mitch Katz, MD, have been “inaccurate, offensive, hurtful and inconsistent with the requirements of JAMA.”
Katz is an editor at JAMA Inside Medication and CEO of NYC Well being + Hospitals in New York Metropolis.
Additionally deleted was a JAMA tweet selling the podcast episode. The tweet stated: “No doctor is racist, so how can there be structural racism in well being care? A proof of the thought by medical doctors for medical doctors on this user-friendly podcast.”
The incident was met with anger and confusion within the medical neighborhood.
Herbert C. Smitherman, MD, vice dean of range and neighborhood affairs at Wayne State College Faculty of Medication in Detroit, famous after listening to the podcast that it was a symptom of a a lot bigger downside.
“At its core, this podcast had racist tendencies. These attitudes are why you do not have as many articles by Black and brown folks in JAMA,” he stated. “Folks’s attitudes, whether or not aware or unconscious, are what drive the insurance policies and practices which create the structural racism.”